Is Business Intelligence a dodo bird?


The last Dodo bird was killed in 1681. Darwin told us that “it is not the strongest of the species that survives, not the most intelligent that survives. It is the one that is most adaptable to change”. The world in which Dodo birds existed changed with the arrival of humans and they, the birds, did not adapt. The world in which business intelligence (BI) exists is changing, changing pretty drastically. Will BI go the way of the Dodo bird?

It wasn’t that long ago when C-level execs would ask simple questions like who are my top ten most profitable customers or what are my least profitable products. Then people like me would go off to build large enterprise data warehouses in an attempt to provide them answers. These projects were big and expensive with high failure rates. It was at about this time, the mid-1990’s, that I had made the observation that companies such as Oracle or SAP could pre-build a data warehouse using their ERP applications as the source. After all, the source data from one customer to the next was the same, for the most part. So were many of the questions. Apparently, I wasn’t the only one who saw this opportunity. Eventually, Oracle offered Daily Business Intelligence, SAP had The Business Warehouse, and Siebel provided prebuilt analytics for a number of different ERP applications.

While these systems were a step forward, they were not the hoped-for cornucopia of business insights. They were still IT-centric systems. They also needed to be integrated with other systems, systems outside of traditional ERP. A packaged data warehouse would also have to be extended to include data that wasn’t necessarily part of the packaged BI application, even though that data might be in the original source system. In addition, the systems may have been integrated on the back end, but the dashboards and reports still seemed to be a separate thing, a separate application to which the user needed to navigate.

Of course, as BI evolves so too does the business environment. We hear young lions roar; “The business environment is changing at an exponential rate! Organizations are becoming more customer centric! The Internet changes everything! Wait… I mean the cloud changes everything! Nope, I meant the Internet of Things (IoT) changes everything!” We have heard these grumblings ad nauseam. Behind these clichés, however, are some very real truths.

The variety of data sources has grown as well as the types of data. With IoT the scope of connectedness has exploded. There are approximately 2.5 devices for every person on Earth. Yet, only slightly half of the world’s population has Internet access which would lead us to conclude that the average number of devices for people with Internet access is roughly five devices. The variety of device types has driven a diversity of data as well. Data has grown drastically from simple structured data locked within internal systems to unstructured text data, images, and videos to give just a few examples. Not only have we been told of these changes on every blog and in vendor presentations, we have lived through it. We have been part of this changing ecosystem. The real question for BI is how do we adapt to meet this changing environment.

First, we need to create an environment in which the user can truly interact with the data. Understand that this is more than just drilling down, more than merely slicing and dicing. By interacting with the data, I mean that the user can go places in the data that may not have been anticipated by the system architect. The user should be able to do more than simply create a new report, but to be able to explore the data possibly defining new relationships within it.

Second, the data with which these users interact need to go beyond the walls of the organization. BI data now exists in the cloud. BI systems will need to access the data within cloud applications and data sources. This will drive an increase in the volume, diversity, and complexity of data.

Third, greater connectedness will also mean an increase in speed. Organizations will need to respond much more quickly to trends that are both market and individual based. To deal with this we expect to see a growth in the use of both predictive and prescriptive analytics.

It is pretty obvious that BI has changed over the years, and it continues to do so. Although Gartner has declared BI dead, I do not believe it to be the case. With all due respect to Gartner, far from being dead, we are on the cusp of a new stage in the evolution of business intelligence. As BI adapts to this changing environment people are empowered to be more effective through information, from the board room to the loading dock. BI is far from the Dodo bird of information systems.

11 thoughts on “Is Business Intelligence a dodo bird?

    • Tim, that is an interesting point. I know that Domo has been getting some real attention in the market. Unfortunately, I am terribly familiar with it. Do you think it is beginning to achieve this future state? Where do you see its short comings or its strengths in this regard?


      • With the ETL built into Domo and the ability to leverage AWS Redshsift SQL there really isn’t a need for a true Data Warehouse. It therefore places all the power into the capable hands of the business however you do still need to be able to write SQL to do anything extremely powerful. I think the vision of self serving true analytics is not necessarily feasible. You have to have experience handling data to serve yourself accurate insights . Domo lacks in troubleshooting SQL in ETL and puts a large burden on Operations to manage the data which IT typically had DBAs for. I really thought I was going to hate Domo but after 2 years of using it and seeing how they are addressing problems and adding features almost daily I foresee it as a part of the Microsoft package in the near future. Overall, most innovative BI tool I’ve seen and I’ve used almost all of them.


  1. I’m handclaping right now!
    Did anybody claim DSS or EIS systems dead when BI was born? Was it pure marketing and a naming operation?
    Or just evolution? Because it was not a disruption.
    Could we extend our BI systems with AI, or ML based analytics? Of course. Some BI systems are already doing it. Or will be ble to.
    Whats new then? More data? New data? Structured? Unstructuref? Do you need some ETL to extract information from it. Of course not. They use data prepatation cloud platforms. (LOL).

    Liked by 1 person

  2. BI isn’t dead it’s evolving just like every other area of IT. Old BI best practice still provides the basis for the core systems but we now have more data sources with the advent of the IoT and greater processing power with NoSQL databases. This is a good article and the people at Gartner clearly are trying to make a splash with a (foolishly) provocative statement.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. This is an excellent article which i wholeheartedly agree with. I designed and built EIS dashboards back in the 90s, and in many ways not that much has changed. Industry analysts like to create new terms and acronyms to draw attention to themselves, Gartner being the prime villain. Tableau really is a Decision Support System. The one area where i think significant change will occur (actually already occurring) is automation. Natural Language Generation algorithms are able to displace (some) of the work of a business analyst, automatically identifying trends, outliers and correlations, and then creating professional narrative for a report or audio briefing, Automation will also be able to bypass the visual analytics that the data discovery wave has brought us, and automatically generate insights, even decisions for us. I think we need to clearly identify human strengths (e.g. judgement) and machine strengths (e.g. speed, accuracy) and blend the two for better data-driven business, or we are all in deep trouble!


  4. Great article! I’ve been delivering BI solutions since 1980 and agree with what you say.
    I don’t/can’t agree with Gardner.
    I’m selling BI still now with SplashBI and this product together with a number of competitive products I see are all evolving to deliver against the needs you reference.


  5. Pingback: Business Intelligence is Corporate Fat! | Meditations on BI and Data Science

  6. Pingback: From Data Literacy to Transliteracy | Meditations on BI and Data Science

  7. Pingback: Business intelligence is not on the way out … but ETL may be – Maja Ferle

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s